top of page
Pamphlets cover for Anti-vaxxers and the Texas measles outbreak, using archival CDC vaccination campaign materials from the 1960s.

Anti-vaxxers and the Texas measles outbreak

2 days ago
6 min read

Updated: 21 hours ago

Thank you, Alden Friend


Pamphlets extends a heartfelt thank-you to Alden Friend for contributing this essay. We are proud to publish their research, perspective and commitment to defending public health.


By Alden Friend | Political Science and International Relations


Cover: ARCHIVE — U.S. measles-vaccination campaign materials from the 1960s. Photograph: CDC, Public Health Image Library, image 7500. Public domain; available free from CDC. The image does not depict the 2025 outbreak.


In January 2025, the United States experienced one of its most serious recent measles outbreaks, centered in West Texas. The Texas Department of State Health Services declared the outbreak over on August 18, after 762 confirmed cases, 99 hospitalizations and two deaths among school-aged children. More than two-thirds of cases involved children, and both children who died were unvaccinated and had no known underlying conditions. Behind these numbers are families and communities confronting an illness that vaccination can largely prevent.


This outbreak was not an inevitable tragedy. In this essay, I argue that anti-vaccine rhetoric has helped undermine collective protection through four connected mechanisms: false claims about vaccine safety, the spread of misinformation through social media, nonmedical exemptions that leave communities vulnerable, and the politicization of public-health measures by far-right actors. These forces do not tell us why every individual family declined or missed a vaccination, but together they help explain the conditions in which measles was able to spread.


The persistence of vaccine misinformation


One of the most persistent drivers of vaccine hesitancy is the claim that the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine causes autism. This myth grew in part from Andrew Wakefield’s now-retracted 1998 study, which was discredited by the scientific community. Subsequent large-scale studies have not found a causal link between MMR vaccination and autism. A 2019 Danish study of 657,461 children found no increased autism risk after MMR vaccination, even among children considered at higher risk. The continued circulation of a discredited claim is especially troubling when parents are trying to make decisions about their children’s health.


The evidence for vaccination is substantial. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, two doses of the MMR vaccine are about 97% effective at preventing measles. Yet anti-vaccine campaigners continue to frame a proven public-health achievement as a threat. The result can be an atmosphere of suspicion in which alarming anecdotes are given more weight than careful scientific research.


Measles spreads easily wherever people lack immunity. An unvaccinated person may make a decision that appears individual, but the consequences do not stop with that person. Infants too young for routine vaccination, people with certain medical contraindications and others who are more vulnerable depend partly on the immunity of those around them. This is why I view vaccine refusal not only as a personal decision, but as a question of collective responsibility.


Social media and the circulation of falsehood


Social media has made anti-vaccine claims easier to encounter and repeat. Sensational posts that portray vaccines as dangerous can circulate alongside scientific guidance, often without the context a reader needs to evaluate them. A 2018 study by Soroush Vosoughi, Deb Roy and Sinan Aral examined the spread of true and false stories on Twitter between 2006 and 2017. Across the stories studied, false information reached people more quickly and spread more broadly than true information. Human sharing was an important part of that pattern.


That study did not examine the 2025 Texas outbreak, nor did it establish that a particular recommendation algorithm caused a particular family to refuse MMR vaccination. Its findings do, however, illuminate the information environment in which vaccine myths travel. Platforms that compete for attention have incentives to elevate material that provokes surprise, fear and outrage. When the subject is medicine, the cost of such an environment can be much higher than a misleading political rumor.


Anti-vaccine influencers can take advantage of these systems to make fringe claims appear ordinary or widely accepted. A parent encountering the same allegation repeatedly may mistake repetition for evidence. Public-health workers are then forced to explain decades of research again and again, while emotionally charged misinformation can be shared in seconds. The political question is whether platforms and public institutions will take responsibility for making reliable health information accessible rather than leaving communities to navigate the confusion alone.


Digitally colorized transmission electron micrograph of a measles virus particle.

FILE — Undated, digitally colorized transmission electron micrograph of a measles virus particle. CDC / Cynthia S. Goldsmith; William Bellini, Ph.D., Public Health Image Library, image 10707. Public domain; available free from CDC.


Nonmedical exemptions weaken collective protection


Texas allows parents to seek exemptions from school vaccination requirements for reasons of conscience, including religious belief. These are different from exemptions based on medical necessity. The state’s 2024–25 school immunization report recorded 93.24% of kindergarten students as fully vaccinated against MMR, while 3.76% had conscientious exemptions. For a disease as contagious as measles, even relatively small gaps in vaccination can matter, particularly when unvaccinated people are concentrated in the same community.


Around 95% immunity is commonly cited as the level needed to prevent sustained measles transmission in a population. The statewide school average cannot tell us the exact level of protection in each town, school or family. It also leaves out homeschooled students and children attending nonaccredited private schools, as Texas health officials explain. These limitations should make us more attentive to local vulnerability, not less concerned about it.


Nonmedical exemptions can turn an individual objection into a wider public-health risk. Religious or conscientious beliefs may be sincere, but belief itself cannot provide the biological protection that immunization provides. When exemptions cluster, a preventable disease finds opportunities to spread. Infants, immunocompromised children and others who rely on community protection may pay the price for decisions over which they had no control.


The far right’s politicization of public health


The anti-vaccine movement has increasingly intersected with far-right politics, especially where opposition to public-health requirements is presented as a test of personal freedom or political loyalty. During the COVID-19 pandemic, vaccination became entangled with partisan rhetoric, and that antagonism has spilled into arguments over childhood immunization. In my view, political actors who turn scientific questions into identity tests make it harder for communities to protect themselves.


There is measurable evidence of a shift in attitudes, even as most parents still support childhood vaccination. A KFF national poll conducted in January 2025 found that 26% of Republican and Republican-leaning parents said they had delayed or skipped some childhood vaccines, compared with 13% in 2023. Among all parents surveyed, the share increased from 10% to 17%. This was a national survey, not a survey of families involved in the Texas outbreak; it cannot tell us what motivated any particular infected person. It nevertheless points to a wider change in the political climate around vaccination.


Texas legislation shows how disputes over vaccination have become an arena of partisan conflict. Senate Bill 7, enacted in 2023 and effective in 2024, restricted private employers from requiring COVID-19 vaccination as a condition of employment. It did not abolish school MMR requirements, and it should not be confused with the rules governing childhood immunization. Its relevance here is the broader political debate over whether the state should encourage, require or oppose measures designed to limit the spread of infectious disease.


I am criticizing the far-right political project that makes hostility toward collective protection a badge of loyalty. That does not mean every conservative parent opposes vaccination, nor that every family missing a dose has been persuaded by political propaganda. Access to health care, trust in institutions and the availability of reliable advice also matter. But none of these complexities makes the deliberate spread of anti-vaccine misinformation less dangerous. We should be able to discuss legitimate concerns without allowing politicians and influencers to dismiss the evidence altogether.


Defending a public-health achievement


The Texas outbreak exposed what happens when immunity weakens and misinformation gains ground. Ending it required difficult work by local clinicians, public-health officials and community members. The Texas health department credited testing, vaccination, disease monitoring and public education in its response. These are practical achievements, carried out by people whose labor and expertise deserve recognition.


The lesson is not to accept a cycle of outbreaks and avoidable deaths. Texans should take decisive collective action: scrutinize nonmedical exemption policies, challenge false health claims, hold social platforms accountable for how misinformation circulates, defend accessible immunization programs and demand that elected officials take public-health evidence seriously. Organized community pressure, education and reliable medical services can protect people who might otherwise be left behind.


The January 2025 measles outbreak was not an inevitable tragedy. It showed what can happen when fear, misinformation and political hostility undermine a shared defense against disease. The consequences of inaction are clear: more outbreaks, more hospitalizations and more deaths. Vaccines are one of humanity’s greatest achievements. Protecting that achievement demands solidarity, organized public action and a commitment to the health of everyone, not only those who can protect themselves.


More from Pamphlets: America · Theory & Analysis.


1 Comment


Alden Friend
1 day ago

DISCLAIMER: I initially wrote this as an academic paper, and the Pamphlets team was kind enough to translate it into an article format. Substantial changes were made, so if you would like to see the original or discuss this article with me, you may contact me personally via email. Thank you to the Pamphlets team and the readers.


  • Alden Friend


friendalden@gmail.com

Like
bottom of page