
ASEAN–China Sea Code Slips to 2027 With Core Rules Still Unsettled
ASEAN and China have pushed negotiations on a long-promised South China Sea code of conduct into 2027, despite reaching provisional agreement on roughly 80% of the draft text during the Philippines’ year as chair of the Southeast Asian bloc.
Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro announced the result in Manila on Sunday, November 15, after the first day of the 49th ASEAN Summit. She said the parties had increased the share of provisionally agreed paragraphs from about half of the draft to nearly four-fifths through nine negotiating rounds and two senior-official meetings in 2026. Singapore, which takes over ASEAN’s rotating chairmanship next year, will inherit the unfinished talks.
“Definitely, there is no conclusion yet,” Lazaro told reporters, according to Channel News Asia. She said another five or six months might be enough to finish the negotiations, while stopping short of promising a deadline.

The percentage is substantial, but it does not settle the most politically difficult questions. Of four milestone issues identified by Manila, the parties resolved only how the proposed code relates to the non-binding 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties. They agreed that the older declaration provides the foundation for the new document.
Still open are whether the final code will be legally binding, which waters it will cover, and how important terms such as “self-restraint” will be defined. Those questions determine whether the document can constrain behavior during a crisis or merely offer another diplomatic reference point after an incident has occurred.
The Philippine News Agency reported that negotiators also provisionally agreed to make the code a platform for voluntary maritime cooperation consistent with the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea. Lazaro said the parties reaffirmed commitments to maritime safety, freedom of navigation and overflight, and the prevention and management of incidents at sea.
That language places cooperation beside deterrence. It also reveals the central problem: an agreement designed to manage disputes must be acceptable to China and all ten ASEAN members, including states with no direct claim and claimants with different priorities. Beijing says its conduct is lawful and rejects the 2016 arbitral ruling that found no legal basis for its sweeping historic-rights claim. The Philippines treats that ruling as part of the legal framework for the sea. Several other ASEAN states have overlapping claims or exclusive economic zones.
The delay therefore matters beyond the drafting table. The South China Sea carries enormous commercial traffic and has become a site of recurring encounters among coast guards, fishing fleets, naval forces and survey vessels. Manila’s recent defense pact with Australia aims to make joint operations easier, while China’s economic ties with Southeast Asian states continue to deepen. A code that can prevent miscalculation would have to operate inside both realities.
Progress this year should not be dismissed: monthly talks produced more agreed language than negotiators had at the start of the Philippine chairmanship. But “80% complete” can obscure where the hard bargaining sits. If the remaining provisions decide legal force, geographic reach and permissible conduct, the final fifth may carry more practical weight than much of the text already bracketed off.
Singapore will now be judged less by whether it can announce a finished document than by whether the final rules are clear enough to guide ships and governments when tensions rise. The distinction is important. ASEAN has shown that it can conclude binding region-wide agreements, including the digital-economy pact signed this weekend. Whether China and the bloc can do the same on contested waters remains unresolved.



Comments