top of page
International Criminal Court building and sign in The Hague in 2024

ICC Closes Afghanistan Probe That Could Examine U.S. Forces as Prosecutor Appeals

21 hours ago
3 min read

International Criminal Court judges have formally closed the original Afghanistan investigation that could have examined alleged crimes by United States military and intelligence personnel, while allowing a separate investigation focused on alleged Taliban crimes since 2021 to continue. The decision was dated November 12 and published on November 13; the prosecutor’s office says it has appealed.


The court’s original Afghanistan situation was authorized in 2020 and covered alleged crimes committed on Afghan territory from 2002 onward. Its scope included the Taliban, former Afghan government forces, U.S. troops and U.S. intelligence personnel. The investigation had already been narrowed in practice after prosecutors deprioritized lines of inquiry involving American personnel, citing the difficulty of obtaining evidence and focusing resources elsewhere.


In the nine-page ruling, Pre-Trial Chamber judges said prosecutors had not shown that they could effectively continue the original investigation. The chamber therefore ordered the record closed. The judges also made clear that the decision does not prevent the separate “Afghanistan II” investigation from proceeding.



The prosecutor’s appeal matters because the closure does more than tidy up an inactive file. It removes the court’s remaining formal route for investigating allegations involving U.S. personnel in Afghanistan, as well as an inquiry involving Islamic State Khorasan. The decision does not erase the allegations or declare that no crimes occurred. It says the prosecution has not demonstrated that it can investigate them effectively under present conditions.


That distinction is essential. A court can close a case because evidence cannot be secured without endorsing the conduct under examination. But the outcome still reveals a structural weakness in international justice: the institutions asked to investigate powerful states depend on cooperation those same states can refuse.


The United States is not a member of the ICC and rejects its authority over American nationals, although Afghanistan joined the court’s founding treaty and the ICC maintains jurisdiction over crimes committed on the territory of member states. Washington has imposed sanctions on the court and current or former staff members, objecting both to scrutiny of Americans and to arrest warrants involving Israeli officials.


Earlier Saturday, Pamphlets reported on Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s warning that the administration would use power against the court and his rejection of international legal restraints on the United States. The new Afghanistan decision does not establish that U.S. pressure caused the chamber’s ruling, and the judges cited investigative limits rather than sanctions. The political context nevertheless cannot be ignored: investigators face practical isolation while Washington publicly threatens the institution.


The surviving Afghanistan II investigation focuses on alleged persecution by Taliban authorities after their return to power in August 2021. The court has unsealed warrants for four senior Taliban figures accused of gender persecution against women, girls and LGBTQI+ people. Those warrants remain in force, and the November 12 decision states explicitly that the newer investigation is not closed.


That split creates an uneven record. Allegations against Taliban leaders remain active, while the path for examining alleged crimes by U.S. personnel and former Afghan forces has been shut. The legal reasons may differ, but international justice is judged by whether it can reach all alleged perpetrators rather than only those with the least power to resist it.


The prosecutor’s appeal now gives the court an opportunity to clarify what investigative steps were attempted, which obstacles proved decisive and whether a dormant inquiry truly had to be terminated. Transparency is especially important because the ruling’s public version provides limited detail about the evidence problem.


For Afghans who endured two decades of war, this is not an abstract institutional dispute. Accountability was repeatedly promised by foreign governments, international organizations and successive Afghan authorities. Closing an investigative route without a public accounting risks reinforcing the belief that legal systems pursue defeated or isolated actors while shielding the forces of powerful states.


The ICC cannot compel cooperation through military or economic force. Its authority depends on states, evidence and the willingness of judges and prosecutors to withstand pressure. That makes the Afghanistan appeal a test not only of one investigation, but of whether international criminal law can credibly apply the same standard to Washington, Kabul and the Taliban.

Comments


bottom of page