top of page
A horse-drawn carriage at the south end of Central Park, photographed March 3, 2024.

Mamdani Outlines Carriage-Worker Aid as Union Demands Guarantees

9 hours ago
3 min read

File photograph · March 3, 2024: a horse-drawn carriage at the south end of Central Park. Photograph by Mike Peel, Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0. Archive image, not the November 2026 announcement.

Mayor Zohran Mamdani has outlined support for roughly 200 New York City horse-carriage workers facing the loss of their industry, including career training and a goal of buying back owners' medallions. The November 17 announcement gives the transition a proposed delivery structure, while leaving payment amounts and the financial protection of affected households unresolved. City Hall's framework promises a fuller plan by April.

The Department of Small Business Services would manage a new program operated by LaGuardia Community College, working with NYC Talent. Drivers and stable hands would receive career guidance, training, help accessing education and tuition assistance, and connections to employers. The administration also plans to study electric carriages and pedal-assist bicycles as possible alternatives. Those are proposed services and options; the release establishes neither completed buybacks nor replacement jobs.

The Transport Workers Union remains opposed to the Council's phaseout measure. In amNewYork's November 17 reporting, international president John Samuelsen warns that assistance without secure funding could disappear in a fiscal crisis. He says the union still intends to challenge the measure in federal court after the mayor signs it. That is a stated litigation plan, not evidence that a case has been filed or a court has ruled.

The legislation itself makes a distinction that matters to workers. Section 23 of the Council-approved text would require designated city agencies to develop and implement a transition plan and publish it by April 1, 2027. Its minimum provisions include job-placement services, training, hiring events, civil-service guidance and help finding education opportunities. Describing the text as containing no obligations would miss those requirements.

Compensation is treated differently. Agencies would have to consider whether to establish compensation programs for carriage owners. They could consider fair-market values and comparable arrangements elsewhere. The text fixes neither payment amounts nor equivalent-pay replacement jobs. That distinction explains why a city commitment to provide transition services can coexist with workers' fear of losing their income and investment.

The Council approved the measure, known as Romanch's Law, on October 22. It would end ordinary carriage operations by June 1, 2028. Council leaders cited animal welfare and public safety after the death of 18-year-old tourist Romanch Mahajan during a carriage ride that summer. Their stated purpose deserves examination alongside the consequences for the people whose livelihoods the phaseout would end.

As of November 18, the public legislative docket listed a November 4 mayoral hearing as its latest action and showed no signing date or law number. The November 17 worker announcement therefore supplies a new framework, without establishing that the mayor had signed the phaseout bill.

The workforce includes distinct economic positions. In their October 21 letter to the city's corporation counsel, TWU's lawyers describe representing both owner-operators and drivers, including people with interests in medallions, horses, carriages and stables. Compensation for an owner and income protection for a worker without those assets address different losses. The union's constitutional arguments remain its legal position.

A worker-centered assessment of the April plan should ask who qualifies, what support starts before earnings disappear, how payments are funded and whether new work preserves a decent livelihood. The value of the transition will depend on the income and bargaining power workers retain while those services take shape.

Image reuse: the archive photograph and its cropped Pamphlets social-card adaptation are available under CC BY-SA 4.0. Photograph by Mike Peel (www.mikepeel.net); social adaptation by Pamphlets. The source photograph is dated March 3, 2024 and does not depict the November 2026 announcement.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
bottom of page