top of page
The United States Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C., photographed on 10 November 2006.

Supreme Court Refuses Trump Appeal, Leaving $59 Million Grant Injunction in Place

4 hours ago
3 min read

File photograph · 10 November 2006, the United States Supreme Court building in Washington, D.C. Photograph by Jeff Kubina via Wikimedia Commons; released into the public domain and cropped for the web hero and adapted for the social card.

The U.S. Supreme Court on Monday refused to hear the Trump administration’s effort to revive the cancellation of University of California research grants, leaving a lower-court injunction in place while the underlying First Amendment lawsuit continues.

The court’s docket for Trump v. Thakur, case 26-210, records the petition as denied on November 16. The justices offered no explanation, and no justice publicly dissented. That silence matters: denial of review does not decide the case’s merits or endorse every part of the lower-court reasoning. It means the administration failed to persuade the court to intervene at this stage.

The ruling left intact a May decision from the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. That court upheld a preliminary injunction for a class of University of California researchers whose grants were terminated because their work was perceived to express views associated with diversity, equity and inclusion, accessibility or environmental justice.

The Ninth Circuit drew a line between choosing which programs to fund prospectively and canceling grants already awarded through existing programs because officials opposed the recipients’ perceived viewpoints. The panel said the researchers were likely to succeed on their claim that the latter practice violated the First Amendment.

The administration argued that a president may redirect federal priorities and that agencies are not obligated to continue funding projects inconsistent with those priorities. Its Supreme Court petition also challenged the injunction’s scope. But the appellate record says agencies used form letters and topic-based screens to terminate grants without individualized explanations, creating evidence that the cancellations targeted expression rather than neutral program criteria.

The government told the Supreme Court that roughly $59 million remained at issue in grants administered by the National Science Foundation and National Endowment for the Humanities. An earlier settlement permanently restored $19 million in Environmental Protection Agency grants, including work on wildfire smoke, landfill emissions and water management. The wider wave of federal cuts across the University of California system is larger, but those broader totals should not be confused with the narrower amount in this appeal.

The named plaintiffs include researchers in climate policy, water management, medicine and the humanities. Lead plaintiff Neeta Thakur, a physician at the University of California, San Francisco, received funding to study wildfire-smoke risks in communities of color and low-income communities. The lower courts cited evidence that abrupt terminations threatened layoffs, interrupted projects and damaged researchers’ careers and reputations.

That material impact is why the dispute is more than an argument over administrative vocabulary. Public research grants support laboratories, field work, graduate researchers and long-term studies that cannot simply pause while political appointees redefine acceptable subjects. When cancellation is tied to disfavored words or viewpoints, the cost lands on workers, patients, communities and the public knowledge those programs were created to produce.

The Supreme Court’s refusal is therefore a setback for the administration’s attempt to use anti-DEI directives to cancel already-awarded research funding. It is not a final nationwide prohibition on changing grant priorities. The class action returns to the lower courts, where the researchers must still prove their claims beyond the preliminary-injunction standard. Associated Press and Reuters separately reported the denial and its immediate effect.

The case also fits a broader struggle over public capacity. Pamphlets has reported on how federal funding gaps are cutting jobs at the International Labour Organization and how an aging aviation network exposed the cost of deferred public investment. Research funding follows the same political fault line: whether public institutions will be strengthened to meet social needs or hollowed out through ideologically driven cuts.

For now, the protected grants remain in place, and the administration cannot use this rejected appeal to resume the challenged cancellations. The final constitutional judgment is still ahead, but the immediate result preserves research work and reinforces a basic limit recognized by the lower courts: the government’s spending power is not a license to punish disfavored ideas.

Comments


bottom of page