
Video Shows ICE Take Down Pregnant U.S. Citizen During Modesto Protest
File photograph · 31 January 2025 — An ICE Enforcement and Removal Operations officer during a targeted operation in Baltimore, Maryland. Photograph: U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement / Wikimedia Commons, public domain; cropped to 4:3 for the web hero. This archival image does not show the Modesto incident.
Video recorded outside the Stanislaus County jail in Modesto, California, shows federal immigration agents taking 23-year-old U.S. citizen Lizbeth Vargas Andrade to the ground and handcuffing her facedown after her husband shouted that she was pregnant. An agent is also seen directing pepper spray toward her, although the footage does not establish exactly where the spray landed.
Vargas Andrade told CBS News Sacramento that the confrontation began on Sunday, November 15, as Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents moved to detain her sister-in-law and another person in a vehicle outside the jail. She said an agent backed into her, contact occurred, and agents then grabbed her as she tried to keep recording. She said another agent sprayed her before she was forced down.
The video, recorded by her husband Adolfo Talavera Alvarado, provides important but incomplete evidence. ABC News reported that it shows agents trying to arrest Vargas Andrade as she pulls away, an agent directing spray toward her, and agents taking her down moments after Talavera warned them that she was pregnant. It does not show where the spray struck, and it does not resolve every disputed movement before the arrest.
Vargas Andrade said agents accused her of assaulting an officer, an allegation she denies. Her attorney Patrick Kolasinski told ABC that she had not been charged with a crime. The Department of Homeland Security and ICE had not answered questions from CBS, ABC, KCRA or the Guardian by the time their reports were published. The Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Office said its deputies were not involved and referred questions to federal authorities.
Agents held Vargas Andrade for several hours at an ICE facility in Stockton, according to her and her attorney. She was released later Sunday and evaluated at a hospital. She said an ultrasound found no problem with the pregnancy, but the absence of a diagnosed injury does not erase the danger of forcing a pregnant person facedown or exposing her to chemical spray.
The encounter began amid community monitoring of immigration enforcement in California’s Central Valley. Vargas Andrade said she belongs to a local network that records ICE activity and helps residents respond to arrests. She returned to the jail parking lot with her husband and attorney on Monday to demand accountability, telling reporters that the incident would not stop the group from helping immigrants.
That context matters because the confrontation was not a routine immigration arrest of Vargas Andrade. She says she is a U.S. citizen who was observing and filming federal agents in a public dispute. The government’s power to detain immigrants does not make every use of force against witnesses or protesters self-justifying. Nor should an uncharged allegation of assault be repeated as proof when the agency has not supplied its account or released its own evidence.
The footage therefore supports a narrower, defensible conclusion: agents knew Vargas Andrade was pregnant before taking her down, detained her for hours, and released her without a reported charge. Her claim that spray hit her face is consistent with her account and with an agent aiming a canister toward her, but the video does not independently show the spray landing. Reporting that distinction is necessary both to preserve uncertainty and to keep the visible conduct from being buried beneath competing assertions.
The incident also lands as the administration is narrowing lawful immigration routes while presenting enforcement as worker protection. Pamphlets recently examined the Labor Department’s proposed restrictions on employment-based green cards. In Modesto, the immediate issue is more basic: whether federal agents can escalate against people documenting an arrest, then leave the public without a prompt account of why force and detention were used.
Vargas Andrade and her attorney have called for an investigation. A credible review should preserve all available video, identify the agents involved, disclose the asserted basis for detention and test the force used against the government’s own rules. Until DHS or ICE responds, their silence is not evidence that Vargas Andrade’s account is correct in every detail. It is evidence that the public has received no official explanation for conduct already visible on video.




Comments