
Lesser Evil Politics and the Limits of U.S. Electoral Choice
Updated: Oct 14
The argument
When voters are told that every election is existential, but neither major party offers a convincing break with militarism and corporate power, “lesser evil” politics can become a trap. This is an opinion argument about that trap—not a claim that one election alone will cause the fall of the United States.

What happened in 2024
In November 2024, Donald Trump defeated Kamala Harris. The Federal Election Commission’s official results record 312 electoral votes for Trump and 226 for Harris. The outcome deserves explanation, not a story that blames voters as a single bloc. For a related discussion of U.S. foreign policy, read The U.S. does not protect human rights—it weaponizes them..
Why voters chose differently
Harris’s campaign drew left criticism for maintaining support for Israel’s military campaign in Gaza, defending a strong border policy and offering limited economic change. The defeat cannot be reduced to one issue. Pew’s pre-election survey showed voters dividing sharply over the economy, immigration, health care and abortion, while party identity and candidate evaluations also shaped the result.
What “lesser evilism” means
“Lesser evilism” is more than a judgment about one candidate. It is a recurring strategy: ask voters to treat the opposing party as uniquely dangerous, while giving the preferred party little reason to answer demands from its own coalition. That strategy can produce short-term defensive voting and long-term disillusionment. The record of U.S. policy exposes the stakes. Barack Obama apologized after the 2015 U.S. bombing of a Doctors Without Borders hospital in Kunduz, and the CIA's fake vaccination campaign in Pakistan damaged trust in public-health workers. Electoral rhetoric about protecting rights must be measured against what U.S. governments actually do at home and abroad.
Pew Research Center on issues in the 2024 election · Doctors Without Borders on the Kunduz attack · CSIS on the CIA vaccination campaign
Elections cannot settle the question of empire
Washington has used military intervention, sanctions and financial leverage while presenting itself as guardian of an international order. This contradiction is part of the structural critique of U.S. power, regardless of which party occupies the White House. Pew’s review of the 2024 electorate records mixed motivations rather than a single cause of the Democratic defeat. The political challenge for the left is to reach the people alienated by both governing parties and organize them around demands that outlast an election cycle. Pew’s review of voters’ reflections on the 2024 campaign.
U.S. power beyond elections
U.S. power also rests on financial institutions and the dollar's global role. The dollar remained the leading international reserve currency in 2024, according to Federal Reserve data, even as its share of disclosed reserves declined. Local-currency trade, BRICS expansion, sanctions workarounds and alternative payment systems are building practical channels outside Washington's control. That transition is underway while U.S. financial dominance remains substantial; the shift in institutions matters precisely because it is material rather than rhetorical.Federal Reserve data on the dollar’s international role.
The core critique
Lesser-evil voting can shield party leadership from accountability by making fear of the alternative a substitute for delivering popular demands. Many people vote defensively because the consequences of elections are real. The task for an independent left is to organize beyond election day, build durable pressure and offer a program that can win support on its own merits rather than demanding endless patience with the same failures.
Sources and further reading
Sources and further reading: Federal Election Commission, 2024 presidential results · Federal Reserve, the international role of the U.S. dollar




Lì la democrazia non c'è mai stata.
La Corea 🇰🇵 invece è un paese democratico in tutto e per tutto.